Nonbonded intramolecular interactions
- Jirsak
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 12
- Thank you received: 0
7 years 9 months ago #195
by Jirsak
Dear Cassandra authors, dear community,
when I simulate only a single molecule in the box (no LR corrections) in version 1.1 I don't get equal Energy_Total and Energy_Intra. I suspect non-bonded intramolecular contributions are not included in Energy_Intra despite Cassandra manual says they are. When I add Energy_Intra, Energy_LJ and Energy_Elec, I get exactly Energy_Total. Also, looking into the source code, file energy_routines.f90 , one can find the line
which also seems to suggest non-bonded (vdw and q) interactions are not included in intra term.
Could you either confirm or refute my view?
Thanks, Jan
when I simulate only a single molecule in the box (no LR corrections) in version 1.1 I don't get equal Energy_Total and Energy_Intra. I suspect non-bonded intramolecular contributions are not included in Energy_Intra despite Cassandra manual says they are. When I add Energy_Intra, Energy_LJ and Energy_Elec, I get exactly Energy_Total. Also, looking into the source code, file energy_routines.f90 , one can find the line
energy(this_box)%total = energy(this_box)%total + energy(this_box)%intra + energy(this_box)%intra_vdw + &
energy(this_box)%intra_q
which also seems to suggest non-bonded (vdw and q) interactions are not included in intra term.
Could you either confirm or refute my view?
Thanks, Jan
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- jdmoore
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 32
- Thank you received: 3
7 years 9 months ago #196
by jdmoore
The Intra molecular energy only includes the bond energy (0) + bond angle energy + dihedral angle energy + improper angle energy. It does not include the inra molecule vdw or q.
However, mine seems to add up
Total system energy is 378936.094
Intra molecular energy is -38466.638
Bond energy is 0.000
Bond angle energy is 131166.847
Dihedral angle energy is -169633.485
Improper angle energy is 0.000
Intra molecule vdw is -20699.451
Intra molecule q is 470498.175
Inter molecule vdw is -685.945
Inter molecule q is 3716966.778
Number of vectors is 35300
Reciprocal ewald is 37161.213
Self ewald is -3785838.038
Bond energy (0) + Bond angle energy (131166. + Dihedral angle energy (-169633) + Intra molecule vdw (-20699.451) + Intra molecule q (470498.175) + Inter molecule (vdw) (-685.945) + Inter molecule q (3716966.778) + Reciprocal ewald (37161.213) + Self ewald (-3785838.038) = 378936.094.
This number matches what is printed in *prp (with the unit change from atomic to kJ/mol)...factor of 100.
However, mine seems to add up
Total system energy is 378936.094
Intra molecular energy is -38466.638
Bond energy is 0.000
Bond angle energy is 131166.847
Dihedral angle energy is -169633.485
Improper angle energy is 0.000
Intra molecule vdw is -20699.451
Intra molecule q is 470498.175
Inter molecule vdw is -685.945
Inter molecule q is 3716966.778
Number of vectors is 35300
Reciprocal ewald is 37161.213
Self ewald is -3785838.038
Bond energy (0) + Bond angle energy (131166. + Dihedral angle energy (-169633) + Intra molecule vdw (-20699.451) + Intra molecule q (470498.175) + Inter molecule (vdw) (-685.945) + Inter molecule q (3716966.778) + Reciprocal ewald (37161.213) + Self ewald (-3785838.038) = 378936.094.
This number matches what is printed in *prp (with the unit change from atomic to kJ/mol)...factor of 100.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Jirsak
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Jirsak
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 12
- Thank you received: 0
7 years 9 months ago - 7 years 9 months ago #201
by Jirsak
"Energy_Intra: Total intramolecular energy of the system including bonded and non-bonded interactions in kJ/mol"
Yes, that is consistent with my observation. However, it contradicts Cassandra 1.1 manual, which explicitly says:jdmoore wrote: The Intra molecular energy only includes the bond energy (0) + bond angle energy + dihedral angle energy + improper angle energy. It does not include the inra molecule vdw or q.
"Energy_Intra: Total intramolecular energy of the system including bonded and non-bonded interactions in kJ/mol"
Last Edit: 7 years 9 months ago by Jirsak.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- ryangmullen
- Offline
- Administrator
Less
More
- Posts: 124
- Karma: 4
- Thank you received: 24
7 years 9 months ago #203
by ryangmullen
Hi Jan,
You are correct, the nonbonded vdw and coulombic energies are not currently included in the 'intra' variable. We'll patch that and put up a corrected code shortly.
Thanks,
Ryan
You are correct, the nonbonded vdw and coulombic energies are not currently included in the 'intra' variable. We'll patch that and put up a corrected code shortly.
Thanks,
Ryan
The following user(s) said Thank You: Jirsak
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- Jirsak
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 12
- Thank you received: 0
7 years 9 months ago #205
by Jirsak
Hi Ryan,
thank you very much for your response. I am glad my understanding was correct. I wanted to be sure I am evaluating appropriate intramolecular energy to compare between ideal gas and condensed phase.
Best regards
Jan
thank you very much for your response. I am glad my understanding was correct. I wanted to be sure I am evaluating appropriate intramolecular energy to compare between ideal gas and condensed phase.
Best regards
Jan
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.117 seconds